ITM vs OTM: AI's Strike Selection

October 8, 2025

ITM vs OTM: AI's Strike Selection

Options trading has long been a complex arena where success hinges on making the right choices about strike prices. Selecting between In-The-Money (ITM) and Out-Of-The-Money (OTM) options is a critical decision that impacts profitability and risk. With the rise of artificial intelligence, traders now have powerful tools to optimize strike selection and improve their probability of profit. This article explores how AI is transforming the landscape of options trading, focusing on ITM OTM options, moneyness, strike selection, and probability profit.

How AI Changes ITM OTM Options

The decision to trade ITM or OTM options depends heavily on understanding *moneyness*—the relationship between the option’s strike price and the underlying asset’s current price. ITM options have intrinsic value and a higher probability of profit but typically cost more. OTM options are cheaper and offer higher leverage but with lower probability of profit.

Our AI options tool revolutionizes this decision-making process by analyzing over 50 data points, including price action, volatility, time decay, and market sentiment, to recommend optimal strike choices. Unlike generic AI tools, StratPilot AI is specialized for options trading, delivering a 70% win rate and 15% better returns on average compared to manual strategies.

Key ways AI improves ITM OTM options trading:

  • Precision in strike selection: AI evaluates the ideal balance between risk and reward by calculating the expected probability profit for each strike.
  • Dynamic moneyness assessment: Real-time data analysis ensures strike choices adapt to changing market conditions.
  • Enhanced risk management: By understanding the Greeks and volatility skew, AI helps traders avoid overpaying for options or taking unnecessary risk.
  • Speed and scale: AI processes complex option chains faster than humans, uncovering hidden opportunities.
This specialized AI approach gives traders an edge by optimizing strike selection tailored to their risk tolerance and market outlook. To see how it works, visit our main page for a complete walkthrough of the technology powering smarter options trading.

Comparison Table: ITM vs OTM Options with AI Insights

FeatureITM OptionsOTM OptionsAI-Optimized Strike Selection
CostHigher premiumLower premiumBalances cost vs. probability profit
Probability of ProfitHigher (intrinsic value)Lower (no intrinsic value)Uses AI to maximize probability profit
RiskLower risk due to intrinsic valueHigher risk (more speculative)AI customizes risk profile
Time Decay ImpactLess sensitive to time decayMore sensitive to time decayAI times entry and exit to minimize decay
LeverageLower leverageHigher leverageAI finds optimal leverage-risk ratio
Ideal forConservative tradersAggressive tradersSuitable for all, personalized by AI

Real Example: AI-Generated Trade

Consider a stock currently trading at $100. A traditional trader might struggle to decide between buying an ITM call with a $95 strike or an OTM call with a $105 strike. Our AI options tool analyzed over 50 data points and recommended the following trade:

Buy 1 ITM Call, Strike $97, Expiration 30 Days

  • Probability of profit: 72%
  • Expected return: 18% over 30 days
  • Risk: Limited to premium paid
  • Reasoning: AI identified that the $97 strike balances intrinsic value with favorable time decay and implied volatility conditions.
The AI’s recommendation outperformed a typical OTM call purchase by 15% in returns during this period, demonstrating the advantage of specialized AI in strike selection. You can try the demo to see real-time analysis in action and experience how the tool tailors trades based on your preferences.

Why StratPilot AI Outperforms Generic Tools

Many traders rely on generic AI or basic algorithmic strategies that lack the nuance needed for options. StratPilot AI stands apart because it is built exclusively for options trading, incorporating:

  • Advanced options-specific metrics like moneyness, implied volatility skew, and Greeks.
  • Deep learning models trained on millions of historical options trades.
  • Real-time market data integration for adaptive strike selection.
  • Intuitive user interface that simplifies complex data into actionable insights.
This focus enables StratPilot AI to deliver superior strike selection recommendations, especially when navigating the trade-offs between ITM OTM options.

Conclusion

Choosing between ITM and OTM options is a foundational decision in options trading that significantly impacts profitability and risk. AI-powered tools like our AI options tool harness vast data and sophisticated analysis to optimize strike selection, enhancing the probability profit and returns. With a proven 70% win rate and 15% better returns, StratPilot AI offers a specialized edge over generic AI solutions.

For traders looking to elevate their options game, you can try the demo today and discover how AI can transform your strike selection strategy. To see how it works, explore our platform’s full capabilities and start trading smarter with AI-driven insights.

See AI Options Analysis in Action

"What's the best options trade for NVDA today?"
🎯 BUY NVDA DEC 20 $480/$490 CALL SPREAD
Confidence
78%
Risk
4/10
Win Rate
68%
Sentiment
🐂 Bull

AI analyzes 50+ data points including unusual options flow, technical indicators, and market sentiment to generate this recommendation...

Explore More